MigrationNovember 18, 20263 min read

Amanda Smail-Carrizalez dies about a month after family's move from Butler to Mexico

Amanda Smail-Carrizalez, who moved to Mexico with her husband and their 7-year-old daughter following his detention by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, has died, according to the Tamaulipas Attorney General's office. Her cause of death is unknown.

lake-ubemkbtzelugrrtocnlwolb9-a5d025b1-b0e8-4aa7-b3c9-a5dc5910a498-0.webp

Death reported near family's new home

An official with the attorney general's office said a woman sharing Smail-Carrizalez's name had been found near Estacion Manuel, where the family was living. On Tuesday, several acquaintances posted that she had been found dead. A relative remembered her as a beautiful soul and expressed the family's love and grief.

The Butler Eagle said it had contacted her family seeking more information. Smail-Carrizalez was married to Ignacio Carrizalez, a Mexico native and former Butler, Pennsylvania, resident. Their daughter is Dani Carrizalez.

The family left Butler in October 2026 and drove to Estacion Manuel, Ignacio's hometown in southern Tamaulipas, to live with his parents. The small town is nearly 2,000 miles from Butler.

During the weeks before her death, Smail-Carrizalez used social media to voice frustration with the Trump administration and her husband, as well as unhappiness about adjusting to Mexico.

A life in Butler interrupted by detention

The couple married in 2012 and had been together for 17 years, according to the Butler Eagle. In 2015, they bought a house in Butler and renovated it. After a high-risk pregnancy, Smail-Carrizalez stayed home to care for their child, while Ignacio worked constructing houses from the ground up.

Ignacio had lived in the United States for years without legal documentation. More recently, he had documentation while he and his wife worked through the immigration system. Masked ICE agents reportedly detained him without a warrant in Evans City. He spent more than two months at Moshannon Valley Processing Center in Clearfield County, where conditions and the treatment of detainees have been the subject of allegations.

Smail-Carrizalez brought the family's experience to the Butler County Commissioners on June 17, 2026, describing it as the 51st day of her husband's detention. She asked commissioners to reconsider the county's cooperation with ICE on immigration enforcement. Roughly a dozen supporters gave her their allotted public-comment time so she could keep speaking.

That cooperation included a 287(g) agreement Sheriff Michael Slupe signed with ICE in June 2025. Twelve deputies finished the required training that August or September and started participating in ICE operations in November. Between November 2025 and February 2026, the sheriff's office assisted ICE in detaining 36 undocumented people, according to earlier reporting.

On June 18, 2026, an immigration judge granted Ignacio voluntary departure, initially requiring him to leave the country by July 20. That deadline was later extended to October 16. He was released from Moshannon on July 2, before the family's October move.

Concerns before the move

Before leaving Butler, Ignacio said he feared demands for a "quote," or extortion payment, from corrupt police or cartel members in Tamaulipas in exchange for leaving him alone.

The U.S. Department of State maintains a "Level 4: Do Not Travel" advisory for Tamaulipas because of homicide, kidnapping, carjacking and widespread cartel activity. The cause of Smail-Carrizalez's death has not been established.

Calls for compassion

Frontline Dignity Executive Director Jaime Martinez described the organization as "deeply heartbroken" by her death. He urged people to remember her humanity and "the inherent dignity that belongs to every person."

"In moments of profound suffering, we're reminded of our shared responsibility to meet one another not with judgment but with tenderness and compassion," he said. "We must also recognize the immense emotional and psychological burdens that the ongoing immigration crisis places on families and entire communities.

"These are burdens that too often remain unseen, and they deserve our attention and our empathy."

Slupe offered thoughts and prayers for the family, singling out Smail-Carrizalez's daughter.

lake-17632293-b00f-44ca-ac57-6a4c853bcf47-0.webp
Migration

Families Seek Missing Relatives After Boat Sinks off Ensenada

Families searching for relatives they believe were aboard a boat that sank off Ensenada, Mexico, have come to Tijuana seeking answers from authorities on both sides of the border. Sixteen people were rescued after the Oct. 16 sinking, but 11 others rem...

Diego SalazarOct 29, 20266 min
Back to Migration