How the claims spread
Several clips filmed from different perspectives appear to show a similar winged creature over Ciudad Juárez, in the state of Chihuahua. Mexican journalist Jaime Maussan began sharing three of the videos on November 5.
Maussan is known for covering UFOs, urban legends and unexplained phenomena. On his YouTube show Interestelar, he later changed his identification from a pterodactyl to "clearly a pteranodon." He also suggested the beings could have arrived through "interdimensional portals" opened in the Juárez Valley.
His posts may have encouraged hoaxers to produce more footage. The latest fake clips appeared on November 14 and 15, but whether AI was involved remains uncertain. Snopes identified garbled text and lettering that changes on buildings in the footage, both potential signs of AI manipulation.
Why the footage is being challenged
Sergio Rodríguez, who heads Civil Protection in Ciudad Juárez, dismissed the videos as digital entertainment without any basis in reality. He said Mexico's National Institute of Anthropology and History, or INAH, would have investigated if the footage and creature were real. No such investigation occurred, he said.
Paleontologist Evan Jevnikar challenged both the creature's movements and its appearance. A pterosaur of that size would not flap its wings constantly, he argued, pointing to the way vultures and hawks spend much of their time gliding.
Jevnikar also contrasted the smooth, scaly skin in the videos with evidence that pterosaurs had feather-like coverings. He said the depicted animal resembled a Pteranodon, whose fossils are associated with ancient marine environments in North America, unlike the reported sighting location.
A Reddit commenter raised a separate anatomical objection: the pointed wingtips looked like an outdated, 1990s-era depiction rather than the blunt, rounded tips now understood to have characterized Pteranodon. The commenter's qualifications are not known.
Birds offered as alternative explanations
Another proposed explanation is a magnificent frigatebird, a large bird whose outline can resemble a pterodactyl under certain lighting conditions. That suggestion has not been established as the identity of the animal in the footage.
Elon Musk's AI chatbot Grok offered a different bird identification when X user Chris Costin asked whether the creature was a pterodactyl. It described the animal as "most likely a great blue heron or similar wader," saying that a view from below against the sky could give its silhouette a prehistoric appearance. Grok also noted that pterosaurs became extinct about 66 million years ago.














